PDA

View Full Version : Lost fish on the John Day




Paul Huffman
12-17-2007, 04:06 PM
Last Thursday I went back to the Orthopedic surgeon. He took out the staples in my forearm and put on skin closures and a coveret bandage and told me to try to exercise my fingers and elbow to regain flexibility, but not pick up anything heavy. It sounded to me that he was telling me get out of household chores and to try some two hand casting.

Saturday, White Salmon where I was staying was still stuck under the dreary cloud deck that has stuck around Eastern Washington for the last week. We even got a couple inches of snow. I checked the satellite photos and forecasts and thought, "Hey, it looks like clearing out east." I decided that I better not shovel snow or move furniture. Doctors orders. Instead, I drove out to the John Day where I had a great day under sunny skies and a balmy 42 F. Just me and my chocolate lab all day. I caught one and lost one, so at least I broke my two year two hander jinx. But that lost fish still puzzles me.

I was on my way back to the truck to drive home and decided to make a few casts on the same run where I had landed a small buck earlier. I was fishing a short tip on a skagit head with a heavy lead eyed hareball. This set up seemed to make a good drift but tended to bottom out a lot on the hang down. As I was working down this reach, I completed a swing, let it hang for a moment, then stripped in to the head, and started to stumble downstream for the next cast. It was tough wading with slabby boulders with grass hiding the places to step. When I finally edged downstream far enough, I rolled the line downstream to clear it from the bottom before I started my sweep, but like so many times before, the lead eyed fly was stuck on the bottom. I tried to throw some rolls over it, and when that didn't work, I stripped in the slack and tugged on it from above and the sides. When that didn't work I took a couple steps down and one out to try a different angle on it and to get some more slack to throw over it. I threw some more rolls over it, tightened down and shook it, then gave it slack and threw some more rolls, but it was stuck good. But when I tightened down on it, the snag up didn't seem to be straight below me anymore. Now it seemed to be about 20-30 degrees out in the river. I worried that maybe now I also had a loop of line stuck on a branch or pipe. I decided I was going to have to try to walk down farther, maybe even try pulling from downstream. I stumbled a few more steps downstream and towards the shore, then stripped in the line to try to figure out what I was tangled on. I was almost in to the head and I could almost reach downstream to where I thought the fly was. It looked to me that the line was no longer hooked out in the current and I had a direct pull to where the fly was dead downstream, behind a boulder in the frog water where it was stuck before. I thought I could try a tug almost directly up. As soon as I tugged, that fly took off like a shot, snapping the leader at the tippet knot quicker than I could react.

Did I have this fish on the whole time, from the end of my drift and didn't feel it as I stripped in? Or did it pick the fly up as the line slacked up as I stumbled downstream? Was this a fish of a lifetime, so big I couldn't even budge it with the 10 pound tippet? So big it could hold back and drift out in the current without being bothered by me, not even attempting a perceptible head shake? Or is it harder to feel head shakes with a longer rod? Was the fish made to lethargic by the cold water temperatures to put up much of a fight? The small buck I caught early in the day had allowed himself to be reeled right in.
Did the fish finally panic when it saw me? And why the hell can't I always get them hooked that well?




Jason B
12-17-2007, 04:41 PM
If it felt really firm like the bottom for that long it had to be, at least until you fly was bit by the fish.

I have hooked some huge fish and huge steelies and although big fish can be lethargic and slow at first, it is hard to believe that repeatedly jerking and multiple attempts to unhook your fly wouldn't cause the fish to do something other than act like a snag. I would say this was a snag at first and than a fish.

I have actually hooked a few salmon and trout when coming off snags that they were holding behind.

Another possibility I have heard about is that you can hook fish in some parts of the mouth and it will be so painful that the fish will not fight at all or put up a hugely subdued fight compared to its potential. This may be what happened as well.

Unfortunately, you will never know......

thewaker
12-17-2007, 06:36 PM
Paul,

I think you were snagged then hooked up.
Like jbuehler, I too have hooked quite a few steelhead after the fly becomes dilslodged from wherever it was hung up. Also, another scenario is stripping in after the hangdown,fly hangs up, a fish was possibly following it, you jerk on it till it comes loose, fish on.This is what I believe happened to you. I think sometimes the fish is following/watching the fly moving all around as you try to free it and as soon as it comes loose and tries to escape they hammer it. Just my experience.

Mark

Paul Huffman
12-18-2007, 10:26 AM
I guess so. But to watch a hung up fly twitch and jump for all that time in the shallow frog water then pounce on it when it comes loose seems more bass like than normal steelhead behavior, but there can't be any bass that big in the John Day. Besides, all the bass are in deep sleep this time of year.

Also remember, after I first time walked down a few steps, the location of the hang up seemed to be more out in the river than before. When I pulled in the slack, the line ripped upstream through the current, but when I finally got it tight, the snag didn't seem to move.

Of course, because of this lost fish, I had to work this run futilely for another hour, making me late for dinner.