River closure

Salmo_g

Well-Known Member
#80
The only characteristic that distinguishes a steelhead from a rainbow trout is that steelhead are anadromous. Anadromy is defined as spawning in freshwater and migrating to saltwater. The GL are not salt. There are lots of populations of adfluvial rainbow trout in the world, and that is what GL "steelhead" are, adfluvial rainbow trout. Genetics is irrelevant because genetics has no bearing on migrating between fresh and saltwater. Nor does it have anything to do with God, since the names of fish and the definition of anadromy were developed by humans. Good grief.

Sg
 

FinLuver

Active Member
#84
So what is the salinity of the various Great Lakes versus the Ocean?

And at what point do we call something "salt water", "brackish water" as in estuaries, and "fresh water"?
 

PT

Physhicist
#85
a·nad·ro·mous
əˈnadrəməs/
adjective
Zoology
adjective: anadromous
  1. 1.​
    (of a fish, such as the salmon) migrating up rivers from the sea to spawn.
 

Charles Sullivan

ignoring Rob Allen and Generic
#86
In the same way that atlantics in a lake are landlocked Salmon and kokanee are landlocked Sockeye, I would say that the GL fish are landlocked steelhead. They are steelhead in genetics and behavior. They just can't make it to the sea. They are landlocked, and they are steelhead. Landlocked steelhead.

BTW- They are gosh darn fun to catch. I only wish the streams draining the GL tribs were longer so they behaved more like our fish.

Go Sox,
cds
 

golfman44

5-Time Puget Sound Steelhead Guide of the Year
#88
In the same way that atlantics in a lake are landlocked Salmon and kokanee are landlocked Sockeye, I would say that the GL fish are landlocked steelhead. They are steelhead in genetics and behavior. They just can't make it to the sea. They are landlocked, and they are steelhead. Landlocked steelhead.

BTW- They are gosh darn fun to catch. I only wish the streams draining the GL tribs were longer so they behaved more like our fish.

Go Sox,
cds
By your definition every rainbow trout is a landlocked steelhead. See the problem?
 

Charles Sullivan

ignoring Rob Allen and Generic
#89
By your definition every rainbow trout is a landlocked steelhead. See the problem?
No.

They are landlocked Chambers creek and Skamania steelhead mostly. Not all rainbow strains are likely to become anadromous if given the chance.

There are different rainbow strains from those that tend to become steelhead. Those are also stocked in different lakes.

In the case of landlocked steelhead the original genetics are the same as our fish. The environment is different. Are the Chinook in the GL not chinook cuz there is no saltwater? How about the Coho?

They are landlocked forms of what otherwise would be an anadromous fish. It's no big deal.

Go Sox,
cds
 

golfman44

5-Time Puget Sound Steelhead Guide of the Year
#90
No.

They are landlocked Chambers creek and Skamania steelhead mostly. Not all rainbow strains are likely to become anadromous if given the chance.

There are different rainbow strains from those that tend to become steelhead. Those are also stocked in different lakes.

In the case of landlocked steelhead the original genetics are the same as our fish. The environment is different. Are the Chinook in the GL not chinook cuz there is no saltwater? How about the Coho?

They are landlocked forms of what otherwise would be an anadromous fish. It's no big deal.

Go Sox,
cds
By your definition these fish: http://washingtonflyfishing.com/forum/index.php?threads/anyone-like-bacon.95609/#post-901211 are steelhead. See the problem?

(hint: they aren't steelhead)