I don't believe the WFC would or did trade the Chambers creek fish for an integrated hatchery. I believe what they were after was no Steelhead hatchery on the Skagit and that is what they got, for 12 yrs. What the settlement did was give them a seat at the table if one is proposed, which I believe they would opposed. I think there was a brood program on the Skagit in the 80's that was a failure which will give them some ammo. With the returns to the Marblemount hatchery over the last 10 years what is the value of keeping it or the Nooksack hatchery going?