My thoughts are if she's happy with the $50 and he's happy to take a chance for the $50 it was a great deal for both sides. I'll bet she's smiling to herself for getting rid of that tiny raft that only fit one person and didn't even have a floor. IF she'd asked me how much I thought it was worth and was willing to wait while I unpacked it and tested it then I'd have offered her a more reasonable price. Just my .02 . . .YMMV Brian