spey casting rods, opinions on Scott and Fly Logic

CaddisMadness

Fly Fishing in Patagonia: A Trout Bum's Guide
#16
To each their own. I've just had bad experiences with Scott and have heard similar stories from several others. Even if some people think it's a great rod, the 2-3 month turn-around time on a breakage is unacceptable in my opinion, especially for the premium price. However, my 9'6" 8 SAS has caught more fish and seen more punishment than any of my other rods, and has held up great. Those rods are pretty much indestructable - it's the fancy S3 and ARC rods that seem to be too fragile. Then again, i got them when they were a relatively new product line so maybe some design issues had to be worked out.
 
#18
I had a scott arc 15' #9 that broke the 1st time I used the rod. This was a few years ago. Scott quickly replaced the rod, and upon getting it back, I ended up selling it. I would say that I loved the feel and weight of the rod. Over the years I have purchased about 5 or 6 different Scott rods. I have been happy with all but the 15 footer.
 
#19
With all that advice given, what TFO spey/ two hander Rod do you own and how do you like it.. I have not seem any or little negative feedback about TFO single handed Rods.. I think my intrest is in a 14' 9wt.
I also see you all have good comments about GL Loomis, but they seem to be on the high end with sage rods..
 

Banzai

FFing and VWs...Bugs & Bugs
#20
I tried a 14' TFO this past weekend and found it comfortable and smooth casting for even the rank beginner like myself. At a quoted $250 from the factory Rep, it was the least costly of the spey rods available. Add to that a large arbor reel, a Rio wind cutter w/ tips and you would have a decent set up for most any westside river. IMHO
 

FT

Active Member
#21
Willapabay,

Loomis has 2-hand rods for about $480.00, check their web site for the particulars. Granted, these are more mid-priced rods than lower-priced ones; but they do offer a lot more performance if have the technique to take advantage of it.

The TFO's I've cast have been nice moderate actioned 2-handers, which means they are faster than the ECHO 2-handers that also sell for $250.00. They are made in China; but they are a very good value. For just a $100.00 more you have the Redington (a medium-fast rod series) and the new St. Croix (an action between the Redington and TFO) 2-handers that have more performance built into them than the TFO.
 
#22
Gene Banzai,

Did you test cast your Rainshadow against that TFO? Curious as to how they compared or how you like your Rainshadow spey rod.

Jim
 
#23
I have the Fly Logic 1308. It's a great rod, and after I broke a tip FL rebuilt one for me very quickly -- the new tip does slip at the ferrule after a bit of casting but so what, it still casts great. The rod plays fish well and is strong enough to land them in some awkward (i.e. most) situations. It casts tips and weighted flies just fine (it was designed for it) but is nice with a floater as well. Very versatile. I have 3 other two-handers yet whenever I go steelheading I reach for the Fly-Logic. It's a really good rod.

I reccomend overlining it with an Airflo 9/10 Delta (or whatever the light blue shooting head is).

dn'l