This is always so hard to get across over the internet and we have been here but here goes.... Inland and others aren't arguing that C&R is more ethical and doesn't harm fish. They are arguing that it is a better way to manage the resource than catch and kill. What is more ethical? Treat the fish as a resource? Or treat the fish as a treasure? IMO, most of the time "intellectual honesty" is people thinking way too much and I am as guilty of that as the next guy.