Green Butt Pink, best danged steelhead pattern there is

GAT

Dumbfounded
#1
Well, okay, that statement is up for debate but for me, it is true.

Way back when the Model T was driving the streets, only a few of us in town tried flyfishing for steelhead... especially winter steelhead.

Mike Gorman was the owner of the local fly shop and was bound and determined to come up with a pattern that would fool steelhead. At one of our fly tying sessions, he showed us a pattern he came up with that was working for him. He called it The Green Butt Pink.

It is based on 2. 2 wraps of chartreuse chenille. 2 wraps of pink chenille and 2 wraps of pink dyed saddled hackle. The colors are based on the same as a Clown Corkey.

Simple. So simple you'd think there is no way it would work. For me, 80% of all the summer and winter steelhead I catch are with this simple pattern. I added a clear glass bead with a silver lining but otherwise, left the pattern as it was originally tied.

At his shop, his employees thought it was too simple of a pattern for customers to purchase so, with suggestions from Brian O'Keeffe, they started using a traditional salmon/steelhead hook, made the body longer and added shredded mylar tubing for a wing. They called it The Gay Caballero but that wasn't politically correct so they changed the name to The Caballero.

I once asked Mike if he personally used the Caballero or the Green Butt Pink, he said he still used the Green Butt Pink.

In all its simple glory, here's the pattern that has landed me more steelhead than any other fly:

 

GAT

Dumbfounded
#5
Do you swing it on a tip, high stick nymph it, indicator, dead drift, or all?
All of the above. Except I don't bother with an indicator. It also works to fool SRC.

I was going to say a dead-drift presentation works the best but now when I think about it, I've probably caught just as many steelhead with the pattern at the end of the drift and sweeping downstream.

Almost always, I use two patterns when fishing for any steelhead. The Green Butt Pink is usually one of the two flies.
 

GAT

Dumbfounded
#8
Hmmmm.... the bead size isn't indicated on the package. I buy them at a craft store, I'll need to measure the bead to know the size. The hook is a #2. The bead is not absolutely necessary so I tie the pattern with and without a bead. I think it gives it just a tad more glimmer and sometimes, that's a good thing. However, I caught this hatchery steelhead last year and was using a Green Butt Pink without a bead head so I'll switch up. Normally, I used the bead head version when the water is a little high and maybe a touch off color. I use the non bead head when the water is low and clear... as it was the day I caught this critter.

 
#9
The fly looks non-weighted
How do you obtain the depth you want? Glass bead right? I've used these before but mainly lake - like for an Olive Willy
 

GAT

Dumbfounded
#10
It is non-weighted but I use a heavy wire hook and sometimes a split shot. With a dry line and fairly long leader, I cast a goodly distance upstream so the fly is at the deepest point as it drifts in front of me and then I let it swing downstream.

I once used a steelhead sink-tip fly line system but started catching more steelhead when I went to a dry line and longer leaders. Leader materials sinks much, much quicker than a fly line and I can keep more of a direct connection between the rod tip and the pattern.

If I did plan to use the pattern in deeper water than I do now, I'd probably add a heavier pink metal bead or use lead under wraps for the body but it works fine as-is for me.
 
#11
Very helpful
A heavy wire hook must sink way better than I thought. I'm going to look at doing this over the next few days!
Happy New Year!!
Jamie
 

kelvin

Active Member
#14
Well, okay, that statement is up for debate but for me, it is true.

Way back when the Model T was driving the streets, only a few of us in town tried flyfishing for steelhead... especially winter steelhead.

Mike Gorman was the owner of the local fly shop and was bound and determined to come up with a pattern that would fool steelhead. At one of our fly tying sessions, he showed us a pattern he came up with that was working for him. He called it The Green Butt Pink.

It is based on 2. 2 wraps of chartreuse chenille. 2 wraps of pink chenille and 2 wraps of pink dyed saddled hackle. The colors are based on the same as a Clown Corkey.

Simple. So simple you'd think there is no way it would work. For me, 80% of all the summer and winter steelhead I catch are with this simple pattern. I added a clear glass bead with a silver lining but otherwise, left the pattern as it was originally tied.

At his shop, his employees thought it was too simple of a pattern for customers to purchase so, with suggestions from Brian O'Keeffe, they started using a traditional salmon/steelhead hook, made the body longer and added shredded mylar tubing for a wing. They called it The Gay Caballero but that wasn't politically correct so they changed the name to The Caballero.

I once asked Mike if he personally used the Caballero or the Green Butt Pink, he said he still used the Green Butt Pink.

In all its simple glory, here's the pattern that has landed me more steelhead than any other fly:

Whats the hook?
 

GAT

Dumbfounded
#15
Oh, forgot, it's a TMC800S (or you can use a similar short shank, heavy wire, ring eye hook) size 6. I use 4-6, 4 for off color water.