Hook Manufacturers

KDS

New Member
#1
So I'm looking to replenish my hook collection and went on ebay to snoop around. I usually use Daiichi, but have used Tiemco and others in the past. I came across a guy selling no-name hooks, claiming they are made in the same factory and the "only difference is the name on the package". I'm familiar with manufacturing, having managed a couple of steel plants in a past life, and this actually sounds pretty logical to me. Any thoughts?
 
#2
Sounds logical to me too. It's also logical that the hook companies who rely on their brand being high performance and defect free might have better quality control, and maybe higher specs/tolerances.
 

ScottP

Active Member
#4
I usually use Dai Riki hooks; price is good and quality has been pretty consistent for me. Bought some bargain hooks as well, from a number of vendors and had variable results, mostly deformed eyes and bad barbs like this one on the side; not too big a deal since I mash them all down, but makes for an odd looking fly



Regards,
Scott
 

ScottP

Active Member
#6
Id suggest taking a good look at Allen hooks. A site sponsor and the hooks are very well received by quite a few tiers I know.
Nick,

This was from a pack of Allens



I've had a number of other issues with their hooks and won't be buying from them again; just my experience.

Regards,
Scott
 

golfman44

5-Time Puget Sound Steelhead Guide of the Year
#9
Nick,

This was from a pack of Allens



I've had a number of other issues with their hooks and won't be buying from them again; just my experience.

Regards,
Scott
My buddy just had a brand new Allen hook bend out from a pass lake rainbow which sucked. I bought some from them but am yet to fish them myself.

You can find pretty much any brand on eBay for real cheap if you don't mind buying in lots of 100. I'd go that route if you want a specific brand - - I'm not sure how much you'd save from buying the no name ones?
 
#10
Hooks are one of the things that I always try and buy the best quality. Imagine stalking that 24" brute of a brown and getting that perfect cast and hookup only to loose him because you bought cheap hooks at the shop last week. I've had good numbers of breakoff's with Dai-Riki hooks and some other cheap brands, either when crimping the barb, on fish or snags or just having it come off for no apparent reason. Because of that I never buy Dai-Riki's and wouldn't reccomend them. I mainly fish Gamakatsu and Tiemco hooks and can't remember the last time I broke a hook.
 

David Dalan

69°19'15.35" N 18°44'22.74" E
#11
I like the steelhead irons I bought from allen, but my favorites are Tiemco 7989/7999 and the AJ hooks from Diachi. I'm cheap in a lot of ways, but not usually hooks.

Buy a pack of the low cost ones and take 'em for a text. Even better you can use your vice or a set of pliers to do some QC when you get them.
 

Jim Ficklin

Genuine Montana Fossil
#12
but makes for an odd looking fly
At my age & state of eye sight deterioration, all of my flies look "odd," lol. But they still catch the occasionally equally poor-sighted fish. I have no doubt that quality is better with some brand-name hooks, but I still use Mustad a lot & I'm happy with them. I do intend to try some Allen hooks one of these days. I've also considered tippet rings, but can't find any the size of basketball hoops . . .
 
#14
ote="troutdopemagic, post: 931565, member: 20531"]Hooks are one of the things that I always try and buy the best quality. Imagine stalking that 24" brute of a brown and getting that perfect cast and hookup only to loose him because you bought cheap hooks at the shop last week. I've had good numbers of breakoff's with Dai-Riki hooks and some other cheap brands, either when crimping the barb, on fish or snags or just having it come off for no apparent reason. Because of that I never buy Dai-Riki's and wouldn't reccomend them. I mainly fish Gamakatsu and Tiemco hooks and can't remember the last time I broke a hook.[/quote]
I've had the opposite experience. I've had many bad batches of Tiemco, zero with dai-riki or mustad.
 

Cold

Active Member
#15
I've had "mutants" in packs from nearly every hook maker, but all were within what I'd consider "acceptable" ranges.

Dai-riki do seem a bit more brittle than average, but I've never had an unacceptable level of breakage (basically, in an unrecoverable snag, you're either going to break tippet, bend hook or break hook, and in the situations where the hook gives, Dai-riki tends to break where a similar Mustad or TMC would bend...no better or worse imho, just different), and that's over a sample size of between 500-1000 flies on Dai-riki hooks. For the price, they compete.