OK, I know this has been asked before, and I checked the search function but didn't find exactly what I wanted, soooooo....
If you were wanting to book a winter steelhead trip to an Olympic Peninsula river, in Feb/Mar, Which guide and what river would you choose? Only those with actual first-hand experience need reply please. I would like your best recomendations.
I have never fished with him but do know him: JD Love. He started working as a fisheries technician 25 years ago on the OP and has been fishing it ever since. Unless you had a specific river you wanted to fish, I'd let him make the decision at game-time as to which was fishing best and/or in shape.
iagree Both of these guys have been in business on the OP for a long time. You don't stay in business in areas as remote as the OP unless you are good, very good, at what you do. Talk to them. Feel them out as to how they like to fish. If that's how you like to fish, fish with him. Trust his judgement to pick the river.
Bottom line? Fish or not. Doesn't matter. You got to fish the OP. All of it's rivers are top notch,,, world famous. And you fished with one of the best guides out there. A lot of guys would give their left you know what for that. :beer1:
Thanks guy's for the suggestions so far. Be assured that our intention is to rely completely on the knowledge of the guide we select, to know where, when, and how to have the best shot at actually catching fish.
Is that not the reason to use a guide? I do not expect a guarantee for x-number of fish, but not looking for a nice boat ride either, can do that on our own.
Not into spey fishing, so that is not important. Sounds like JD is a solid option at this point.
LB
Speyfisher, the only thing I'm willing to give up would be $
the OP rivers are pretty fickle during the winter months, clear today, blown tomorrow. JD lives right on the sol duc, i mean right on. he walks out his door and knows what that river is doing. he also has great contacts to check in with regarding the other possibilities.
always let him make the call for the exact day you are drifting. he knows his stuff, usually has a bunch of demo rods with him and will freely suggest his favorite fly of the day and then take great pains to tie it on exactly. the fly always seems to be VERY big and black
now i also have to admit that he was recommended to me years ago and he is the only guide i have ever fished with on the OP. i am sure there are a few other winners out there.
If you want walk in guide service, Bob is an excellent choice. He showed me more than a few good walk in access points that weren't so obvious. He makes one hell of a good hot sandwich too!
Another great option is Bucker... I've jocked him in the past, and I'll continue to do so. Excellent guide, and an excellent casting instructor....
Another excellent guide is Jim Kerr. I haven't fished with him but have friends that have. They had an excellent time. http://www.jimkerrguides.com/
Brian
Surprised no one has beat me to the punch, but Steve Buckner (Northwest Flyfisherman) is a great option. I think his principal beat is the Queets. I've fished with him a couple of times and had a great experience both times.
Bob Triggs. I've fished with him twice and have a third trip scheduled for January. He's knowledgeable, personable, an excellent casting instructor and all around good guy.
I've fished with both Bob Triggs and Jim Kerr (though not for steel with Bob), and can provide an enthusiastic :thumb: for each. Both are great company on the water, have impeccable backgrounds and knowledge, and will hold your hand or let you run as you prefer.
I really don't think you could go wrong with any of the options. If you are really in it for more than the boat ride I would plan on booking multiple days
All Be Damned! I mentioned earlier that jd was a good choice because I had heard that because I was unable to locate the name of the guide that put me right on the fish. Someone mentioned his name earlier. Jim Kerr and they gave a web address. Just look a few post up from mine. I have included a couple of photos from the fish Jim got me into. Two Steelhead. This guy know where the fish are and he to lives in Forks.
Again thanks for all the options. I've been steelheading for 20 years now, and have caught one or two, so I don't want casting instructions, or hand holding.
Not that I can't learn new tricks, but I want to use my own rods, lines and flys.
As I said I just want someone who knows those OP rivers, and optimum run times, and it will be easy now, thanks to all of you, to start checking out a few.
I have fished with both Triggs and Buckner and they are both top notch guides. They will do their damndest to get you into fish. Now as you know with that said if there aren't fish there aren't fish, it is the O.P.
everyone's suggestions are awesome. If you're hankerin' for a shot at fishing the Quinalt, there is only one man I'd recommend. The legend, the Federal tracker, the myth, the cougar slayer, the only man who's trapped a bear cub in a garbage can, broken up more bar fights than Mr. T and tracked ol' Squatch on a TV show (true shit too): Clay Butler. He isn't fly specific, but he flyfishes and understands those who do.
Clay has put me into a lot of big fish over the years.
A great guy. I miss Clay. I don't even know if he's guiding now but I'd fish with him again in a minute.
this does not qualify as first hand experience.
However, I saw Bob Triggs speak recently.
He was excellent and believe he would be a good choice
BruceAC
For walk-in guide service, both Doug Rose and Bob Triggs are excellent choices. If I want to run the river in a boat, I'd plunk my money down with J.D. Love.
Good Fishing,
Les Johnson
jeff brazda is a machine!
one of the hardest working guides
i've fished with. ninja skillz on spey.
swings the fur and nymphs the
beads. whatever the water he's
gonna cover it.
One guide I would highly NOT recommend is Pat Graham..fished the Hoh with him out of Forks once. Don't know (hope he is not) if he still guides this was 5 years ago. Boat not set up for fly-fishing (set up for pulling plugs...nothing wrong with fishing gear but he claimed to be a "fly-fishing" guide), he threw trash in the river, his client gear was in very poor shape and his reels had extremely rough drags, promoted killing whitefish (by smacking off your hook with an oar), the list goes on. Worst fishing guide I have ever used and I have fished with many saltwater and fresh. Advice on what guides not to use I find as important as recommendations on good guides.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Washington Fly Fishing Forum
1.8M posts
21.4K members
Since 2000
A forum community dedicated to fishers, anglers and enthusiasts in the Washington area. Come join the discussion about safety, gear, boats, tackle, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!