Would a brown Carey pass for a March brown?

#1
Waiting for the Seahawk game to start, and got to thinking. Never a good thing for me.

Well, I wondering if a brown Carey Special would pass for a March Brown Nymph?

Say in a #12 2x long?
 
#4
Well, the proof is in the pudding. I think I will tie up a few and try them. Maybe a pair in size 12 thru 18 standard length hooks

See what the trout think of them. Besides, their opinion is more important than mine.

Be a good rainy day project.
 
#6
My sources give a soft hackle.

I have never tied a soft hackle woolie. Hell, I have never even seen a soft hackle woolie. I am thinking a sparse Carey with a sink tip tied in brown.
Be worth a cast of five.

Do bugs read the calendar?
 

Preston

Active Member
#7
It would probably work under some conditions but, if you tie your own flies, why not tie something that more closely resembles a nymph? March browns are clingers and most are probably eaten when they are emerging. The nymphs cling very securely to the rocks and can scuttle with surprising speed into the cracks between the rocks when disturbed. March browns may emerge from the nymphal shuck at the bottom and rise/swim to a point near the surface buoyed by gasses trapped in the folds of their wings to emerge, in some cases the nymph will actually rise to the surface before emerging from the nymphal shuck in the surface film.
 

GAT

Dumbfounded
#12
March Brown nymphs are indeed clingers... which is good for them but not so much the trout.

It's odd. I don't think I've ever caught a trout with a MB nymph or emerger pattern.... never.... ever.

I've tried all the patterns I've heard of that are supposed to work subsurface to represent a not-so dun MB and they have not worked for me.

Dry flies do. Emergers and nymphs don't.

This is very strange because I normally catch the majority of fish I target by using subsurface flies. But when it comes to March Browns, I'm a dry fly or die kind'a guy. If the pattern sinks.... I got nut'n.

So sure. Why not? A Carey Special will work fine to represent a MB nymph... for someone, somewhere but not me :)

(seriously, as the MB is a clinger so the suckers are not available to the trout as are the swimmer and crawler nymphs... (the clinger body shape works quite well to keep them secure) the MBs are much more available to the trout when the bugs emerge ... which means a soft hackle style pattern may be a better way to go than a CS. Stan does quite well using a John's Green during a MB hatch)
 
#13
As naive as I am, I would probably fool the trout into thinking it was something else, and I would swear that they were taking the Carey as a March Brown. Then both the trout and myself would be wrong. But the irony of the situation is that the trout would learn that he was wrong, but I never would. Maybe I had best rethunk this idea.

Besides I am too much of a whoose to fish in March.
 

zen leecher aka bill w

born to work, forced to fish
#14
As naive as I am, I would probably fool the trout into thinking it was something else, and I would swear that they were taking the Carey as a March Brown. Then both the trout and myself would be wrong. But the irony of the situation is that the trout would learn that he was wrong, but I never would. Maybe I had best rethunk this idea.

Besides I am too much of a whoose to fish in March.
Water's low in March and easier for the geezers to wade.