ID help please-mayflies

PBR

Member
Hello. Went creek fishing today expecting to be fishing like size 16-18 bugs then i find a bunch of these darker big guys? The darker one is like a ssize 10-12!

Then there were a bunch of these lighter colored guys. There were larger sizes of the white ones, they seemed to have extremely long tails. Similar in size to the olive one. Never was able to grab one of the larger white ones.

Heck my best fly of the day was a freaking size 10 4xl hook turk turantula. The fish in this creek rarely break 13" lol!

This is from northwest wa btw. North cascades.

Thanks for any help on this. New to fishing creeks.
 

Attachments

Matt B

...
WFF Supporter
Nice! My totally uneducated guess w/o any research is the dark mayfly is a gray drake. I'd guess the lighter one is a PMD. Thanks for sharing.
 

Jim Ficklin

Genuine Montana Fossil
When I was a kid, there was a prolific hatch of those (or something similar in color) on a local walking-distance "crick." We concocted an all-gray dry that the fish would gulp with reckless abandon. Of course, we assigned it the ever-so-secretive name of . . . the "Grey" (the "e" spelling was to fool people, lol. If memory serves me correctly <debatable>, it was crafted with black sewing thread <all I could purloin from Mom's sewing box>, gray hackles & barbs & tips <too large, but beggars weren't choosers> and massive, bulky heads.). I haven't tied one in probably over 50 years; now I'll have to re-create it for old-time's sake!
 
Last edited:

tkww

Member
Nice! My totally uneducated guess w/o any research is the dark mayfly is a gray drake. I'd guess the lighter one is a PMD. Thanks for sharing.
Mine guess is uneducated as well, but I think it might be a Pale Evening Dun.
 

Taxon

Active Member
WFF Moderator
Hi PBR-

Regarding your 1st photo, I suspect this male subimago to be Ironodes nitidus, which has a common name of Slate Maroon Drake.
 

Taxon

Active Member
WFF Moderator
Hi PBR-

Regarding your 1st photo, I suspect this male subimago may be either Ironodes nitidus, which has a common name of Slate Maroon Drake, or Rhithrogena robusta, which does not have a common name.
 

PBR

Member
Sweet. Thanks for the help. Any ideas on the second light mayfly? Is pale morning dun the consensus?
 

Support WFF | Remove the Ads

Support WFF by upgrading your account. Site supporters benefits include no ads and access to some additional features, few now, more in the works. Info

Latest posts

Top