You're correct. The only thing I had a rub with was naming a relatively unknown river. Madison, Bighorn, Missouri, Gallatin, Yellowstone, Beaverhead, Big Hole, Blackfoot, Clark Fork, Bitterroot, Rock Creek. All of these waters are famous for a reason, but I would also even take a little exception to pointing out underutilized stretches of the famous water. I"m not saying people shouldn't offer suggestions to smaller, lesser known rivers, because I realize people that don't live here don't have time to find and explore the lesser known rivers, I just think info like that should be limited to a pm.
Overall, I agree with your sentiment though. I am not a big fan of real detailed info shared on the open forum either. I myself try to keep that to PM’s as well - if shared at all.