It looks like that marine survivals continue to be in the toilet and I am expecting a 2020 PS coho forecast (wild plus hatchery) to similar last year.
As I recall a major factor in shaping the 2019 coho fisheries was the "over-fished" status of the Snohomish wild coho. To deal with that status a high priority in shaping those 2019 fisheries was to achieve an Snohomish wild escapement of 50,000 spawners. Unfortunately the reported of that escapement is only 38,000 - the "over-fished" status of those coho will continue and once again be a dominate force in shaping coho fishing; at least until the returning fish reach MAs 10, 11, 12, and 13.
Honestly, I don't have much confidence in the NOF process. There are many people that have much more in depth knowledge and education for that specific area so I can't judge too much.
A few items that I wish could be changed if they are trying to protect certain stocks of fish.
- Split Area 9 into area 9A and Area 9B. Make a line from the north tip of the Kitsap Peninsula directly west. This could allow more opportunity to the returning fish to the Hood Canal while protecting the Snohomish fish if they are concerned about them.
- Split Area 11 into 11A and 11B. Have Colvos Passage be one part and the east side part be the other, so if the Puyallup fish need to be avoided that would help out.
Last year, I asked why Area 11 was closed in October (the peak of the Coho run is the first week or so) I caught chrome Coho in Area 13 until the middle November last year.
Here is my response from the WDFW:
Not sure how detailed of an explanation you want, so I’ll do my best and you can follow up with questions.
There were a number of wild Chinook stocks that needed additional conservation measures for this year’s fisheries. In order to achieve our management objectives for these stocks and get a fishing permit from NOAA fisheries, we have to craft seasons and fisheries that allow us to meet those goals. WDFW had to make a number of difficult decisions related to fishing seasons throughout Puget Sound for this year. In Area 11, we needed to close the months of June, and Oct through Dec in order to minimize our Chinook impacts and meet those goals. These decisions were made in consultation with our Puget Sound sport fishing advisors and key constituents from Area 11. As to why Area 11 and not 10 or 13, the simple answer is that we have different impacts on different Chinook stocks between Marine Areas and months. The main stocks of concern this year are found in higher proportions in Area 11 in certain months than in the surrounding Marine Areas.
Simply, the closure was due to impacts on Chinook rather than concerns for coho.
The majority of the Chinook are up in the rivers by October-Dec. Seems like a waste of the resource. Allowing beach fishing, certainly, would have a much more limited impact in the Chinook , if any. With the rational, that the emailed response that has does not give me much confidence on the NOF process this year. I hope I'm wrong.
February 28, 2020
Contact: Kyle Adicks, 360-902-2664
Public Affairs contact: Carrie McCausland, 360-902-2262
Salmon forecasts released as salmon season-setting process gets underway for 2020
OLYMPIA – Fishery managers say the coming year may be another tough one for anglers in Washington, with low salmon returns expected again in 2020.
The 2020 forecasts for Chinook, coho, sockeye, and chum salmon – developed by the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) and treaty Indian tribes – were released today during a public meeting in Olympia.
The forecast meeting marks the starting point for developing this year’s salmon-fishing seasons in Puget Sound, the Columbia River, and Washington coastal areas, part of the annual “North of Falcon” process that sets salmon fisheries. A series of public meetings is scheduled through early April to develop tentative fishing seasons for the upcoming year.
WDFW Director Kelly Susewind said that fishery managers will be working hard to find the appropriate balance between meeting conservation objectives and providing fishing opportunities, two key tenets of WDFW’s mission.
“Finding that balance is always a challenge,” Susewind said. “But we work with the co-managers to provide opportunities wherever and whenever we can, while meeting conservation goals.”
The forecasts are based on scientific modeling and a variety of data including environmental indicators such as ocean conditions, numbers of juvenile salmon that migrated to marine waters, and numbers of adult salmon that returned in past years.
The following are summaries of this year’s forecasts, which vary by area:
Columbia River: About 233,400 "upriver brights" are expected to return to areas of the Columbia River above Bonneville Dam, a slight increase from the 2019 return of 212,200 fish, but still well below the most recent 10-year average.
An estimated 181,000 Columbia River coho are projected to our ocean and Columbia River waters, a sharp decrease from the 2019 forecast of about 905,000 fish. Only about a third of that number, 331,500 Columbia River coho actually returned last year.
With the projected weaker coho run and a low Chinook run, salmon fisheries will likely be more constrained than last year, according to Kyle Adicks, salmon fisheries policy lead for WDFW.
“We had strong predictions for last year’s coho returns that ultimately didn’t materialize in the way we expected,” Adicks said.
Washington's ocean waters: The story is similar for the state’s ocean fisheries, with lower numbers of coho projected to return to the Columbia River and to Washington's coastal streams. Ocean quotas for coho will be significantly constrained as compared to last year due to these poor projected returns.
This year's Columbia River mouth forecast of about 51,000 hatchery Chinook to the lower Columbia River is up 2,100 fish from last year's actual return. Those hatchery Chinook - known as "tules" - are the backbone of the recreational ocean fishery.
Puget Sound: Roughly 523,500 wild and hatchery coho are expected to return to Puget Sound this year, representing another decline from 2019 when 737,600 were predicted to return. Projected declines for Chinook in Puget Sound aren’t quite as drastic, with about 256,800 Chinook expected to return to the region, a dip of about 12,000 from last year’s prediction.
In addition, Adicks said that persistent low returns of some stocks – particularly Stillaguamish and mid-Hood Canal Chinook – are likely to continue to restrict fisheries.
WDFW intends to livestream several public meetings, including those scheduled for March 16, March 25, and March 31. The department will provide links to those upcoming livestreams, as well as to the archived video from Friday's forecast meeting, on the website listed above.
Upcoming meetings include:
Ocean options: State, tribal, and federal fishery managers will meet March 3-9 in Rohnert Park, Calif., with the Pacific Fishery Management Council (PFMC) to develop options for the year's commercial and recreational ocean Chinook and coho salmon fisheries. The PFMC establishes fishing seasons in ocean waters 3 to 200 miles off the Pacific coast.
Regional discussions: Additional public meetings have been scheduled around the state throughout March and into April to discuss regional fishery issues.
Final PFMC: The PFMC is expected to adopt final ocean fishing seasons and harvest levels at its April 3-10 meeting in Vancouver, Wash. The tentative 2020 salmon fisheries package for Washington's inside waters is scheduled to be completed by the state and tribal co-managers during the PFMC's April meeting.
The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife is the state agency tasked with preserving, protecting, and perpetuating fish, wildlife, and ecosystems, while providing sustainable fishing, hunting, and other recreation opportunities.