With a
GOTY post like this, I feel like my work here is done.

And yes, great job by Nick putting you guys into scoring position when everyone else was struggling to get on the board. At this rate the days of getting weird looks for walking down the dock with a fly rod in hand will soon be history... if not already.
Well done!!! What were the fish eating?
We're heading back out in two weeks for what we call "Westport: The Sequel".
Steve
Awesome, have fun. Jealous you get to go again!
So to answer your question, let me preface this by saying this was my first time ever doing this, so if someone like Nick (who has put in more days on this fishery than the rest of this forum combined) chimes in and contradicts something I say then listen to him.
Now that we have that out of the way, here's the deal. After 1 day I am obviously an expert tuna roper and the following should be treated as gospel. I just signed my book deal on fly fishing for tuna and we are looking at an early 2022 release for hardcover, and maybe by Xmas 2021 on e-readers. Bezos' people have reached out to me for exclusive rights on the Kindle, but I pushed him off until next week when my arm has recovered enough to pick up a phone.
There were 4 other sports (gear guys) with us, so we were trolling 3 gear rods and 2 fly rods at a time. My #'s might be a little fuzzy but we were hit on the troll in the ballpark of a dozen times (often with 2-3 rods going off at once). The fly rod was without a doubt the most consistent producer on the troll. Of those ~dozen times there was a troll bite, I think there was just 1-2 of them when my rod didn't get hit, and a # of the times the
only hit came on the fly. I chalk this up to the bugs looking more realistic than the other shit.
Of course, it could also be my superior presentation when on the troll. A few times Nick had actually turned the boat a little bit and I got tatter totted, so technically I swung up a few Tuna. All my steelhead dry line swung fish clearly gave me an upper hand in how to properly present a swung fly on the troll. I feel bad for the albacore, they were simply outmatched with a proper swung fly in their face. I mean sure, they have dodged whales and sharks and dolphins and other mildly successful killing machines their whole life, but once they got called up to the big leagues and had to face a well presented swung fly they didn't stand a chance.
The troll hits were absolutely electric. I swing flies for steelhead because of the grab, but no steelhead has sent a jolt up my arm anything CLOSE to even the smallest of tuna. Just insane. Next trip I may just want to hire a masseuse to sit behind me rubbing my shoulder and arm while we are trolling around waiting for the next lightning bolt.
One thing I did notice was there were ~3 fish that didn't stick for me on the troll. I fished tube flies almost exclusively all day so I was able to adjust the hook placement with ease. Once I moved the hook placement further towards the head the conversion rate was solid. Again small sample size, but in my world class expert opinion that mattered. When I had a fly with a stinger hook on, all I got back after a hit was a chunk of fish gills, so the fish obviously took it too deep.
On bait stops the gear guys fishing live chovys did pretty well. No question about it that live chovys out fish flies on a stop. I really don't know how to overcome that: predatory fish like to eat shit that is alive. That doesn't mean flies don't work, but simply that when given the option between a live chovy and some feathers, I understand why a tuna would choose the live bait. One gutted fish easily had 30+ bait fish in its stomach. Granted this was a slow/low odds day: we never saw surface activity, and I only saw one single fish swimming around chasing my fly, so it just wasn't a good day for cast and strip....but still, the chovys were getting it done. I'd like to think that if it was a fly-only trip for everyone on the boat, then cast and strip would have been more effective because 1) more flies in the water and 2) less live chovys in the water that fish could hit instead of a fly. The smoke cover also made it hard to see deep into the water, so there could have been more action than I was seeing, but definitely nothing was boiling up on the surface.
Overall we held our own on the bug rods. Silverfly to your point, let the record show that COTY GOTY and IRA did their part to convert the good people of tunaville into knowing that us feather chuckers are not lepers. It was hilarious at times when I was up on the bow casting and overhearing the action coming from the deck. Hearing Ira take control and barking out directions for the tuna dance was incredibly entertaining. Which reminds me -- the dance is so damn fun. I need to work that program into the steelhead world ASAP. Swung fish on, just charge downstream going over/under everyone in the run. Nobody below you? Run upstream and go over/under the guys above you. Hell I may just find the nearest person to me and go over and under them repeatedly. I don't care, I just want to dance and I need a partner damnit.
Anyways, on the ride in the 4 guys admitted to being a bit nervous when they saw us show up with our own fly rods that morning. Once they saw us in action they had zero issues with it and they were asking a few questions -- their curiosity was definitely triggered. Naturally given the lack of near surface activity, the success on chovys during the bait stops, and being outnumbered 4:2 on gear:fly rods, the gear rods put more total fish in the boat. But again, we held our own.
Seriously though given the conditions and the lack of success from other boats (a boat that plugged in just 1-2hrs weeks ago only found 1 tuna this day), this day shouldn't have been as successful. 110% of the credit goes to COTY
@Nick Clayton, he flat out got it done and was in a class of his own. Also thanks
@DenWor54 for the lesson on tuna fly design, and the rest of you for the posts over the years. When you guys put together another bug trip hit me up!!