Damsel Nymph to match Adult?

#1
My normal go-to damsel nymph which is tied in shades of olive stuck out. I eventually stared catching fish on much darker colored micro leeches. The leeches were, by no means, precise imitations and were not consistent producers. I believe the dilemma arises from a close inspection of an adult which had the normal slender body that was gray with black barring as opposed to the brilliant blue with black barring that I am used to seeing.

Question? What might be the proper damsel nymph design, color, proper tie, etc. to match the adult that was described above?
 

Taxon

Moderator
Staff member
#2
...What might be the proper damsel nymph design, color, proper tie, etc. to match the adult that was described above?
Hi Golden Trout,

With damselfly and dragonfly adults, the males are generally rather strikingly colored, whereas the females tend to be more drab in color. However, this rule does not hold true for their nymphs, which tend to be drab in color, whether male or female. Depending primarily on family, genus, and species, nymphal damselflies may be tan, olive, green, brown, or some combination of those colors.
 

jwg

Active Member
#3
looking at damsels on bug guide, I had no idea they came in so many colors and patterns.
I was only familiar with green and blue.
Jay
 

Preston

Active Member
#6
I would go along with Ralph Cutter in his opinion that "it's impossible to imitate the swimming motion of the damsel nymph, so dont even try". Anyone who has watched the violent, side-to-side gyrations of a swimming damselfly nymph would most likely agree. He adds, however, that, fortunately for the angler, the swimming nymph has to frequently stop and rest, hanging motionless in the water, and the fish is as likely to grab him then as when he's swimming.

Most damsel nymphs I've observed, at least when they're emerging (that is, when crawling out onto some kind of dry surface, be it a cattail stalk or your float tube) are some shade of tan or brown. Even after emerging from its nymphal shuck the adult damselfly hardly ever exhibits its fully-mature adult coloring. I've seen primarily grays, very pale greens and tans. Damselflies exhibit a period of development after ecdysis (emerging from the nymphal shuck) which may last for a considerable period of time (how long, Roger ?) and, during this period are called "tenerals". At this time their wings are longer than their abdomens and the abdomen itself is shorter and stouter than in the adult. They are not yet good fliers and, generally, just hang there, waiting to mature. I've heard that trout will bump against the bases of cattail stalks in an effort to dislodge them, in which case they would most likely flutter down to become a menu item. I've never observed this although I have seen ducks, swimming around and stretching their necks up as far as they can to pick off every teneral they can reach.
 

dogsnfish

Active Member
#7
I was out on a lake yesterday and could see the nymphs swimming by my tube about 6" below the surface and the fish were very active. I had four or five patterns from 14 to 8 and was moving through them with no luck, until I use the skinniest one I had in a size 14. It is very simple, a few strands of maribou for a tail, a couple of short strands for a chin, and a thin dubbed body (I used superfine) with a gold tinsel wing case. That worked for about a half dozen fish 10-14". Any pattern I had where I put on eyes or tried to imitate the flat head would not work. I had used a very dull green dubbing and maribou, but the nymphs were more tan and I am doing to tie some of those up so maybe will have better luck. Fish then started to hit on the surface so switched to adult damsel patterns and had a ball! I ran out of flies except for one to use as a model for future ties, and ended up in Westslope in Spokane trying to figure out the body to tie many, many more adults! Thanks Jesse!
 

Taxon

Moderator
Staff member
#8
...Damselflies exhibit a period of development after ecdysis (emerging from the nymphal shuck) which may last for a considerable period of time (how long, Roger ?) and, during this period are called "tenerals"...
Hi Preston,

My belief is that a damselfly matures sufficiently to fly off within several hours, but am not sure how long they retain the teneral coloration.
 
#12
Hi Preston,

My belief is that a damselfly matures sufficiently to fly off within several hours, but am not sure how long they retain the teneral coloration.
I'm pretty sure I had a couple climb up on my boat out of the water, and in less a half hour was flying. It was really fun to watch, as the wings just seemed to "unravel/grow", flatten out and fly off. The color seemed to remain, but I think she was starting to turn that tan color before flying off. The other did the exact same.
 

Preston

Active Member
#13
I was curious about the length of time required for a teneral to achieve its fully mature adult form. As you can see from the appended pictures, the teneral is still a long way from complete maturity. The abdomen is thicker than in the adult and shorter than the wings, which are translucent; whereas the abdomen of the adult is long and slender, longer than the wings, which are completely transparent. The teneral may be able to fly but it is a rather poor performance compared to the adult which is an agile predator of smaller insects. I've watched adult damsels swoop down to snatch emerging Callibaetis mayflies off the surface.
DSCF1631.JPG
damselfly adult.jpg
 

jwg

Active Member
#14
Once on Amber lake I paid attention to the drowned damsels on the water surface drifting with the wind. All green. not blue.
good to have some green adult or teneral patterns

Probably I was seeing tenerals that blew off the reeds.

Jay
 

Chad Lewis

NEVER wonder what to do with your free time
#15
I believe the drowned green adults you saw were females. I see a lot of the green colored females, and they may die on the water after laying their eggs, although I don't know this for sure.
 

Latest posts