Tippet to fly knots

#1
This past season I have been using a mono no slip knot on by buggers and nymphs. Previously I had been using an improved clinch knot and have been very pleased with the change. However has anyone had experience comparing the no slip knot to a perfection loop for tying on flies or know of someone who has?
 

miyawaki

Active Member
#2
This past season I have been using a mono no slip knot on by buggers and nymphs. Previously I had been using an improved clinch knot and have been very pleased with the change. However has anyone had experience comparing the no slip knot to a perfection loop for tying on flies or know of someone who has?
I would really love to see a video of a perfection loop used to tie a fly onto a tippet!

Leland.
 
#3
Using a Perfection loop is a tradeoff. A nice, straight loop at the end of the line but less strength (using a Perfection Loop reduces tippet breaking strength by ~15%). I like it on the butt end of a leader for attaching loop-to-loop with a welded loop on the end of a fly line when losing a little breaking strength off a 15-20lb test leader won't likely make a difference. The non-slip mono loop is a 100% tippet strength knot . . .ideal for attaching the fly.
 
#5
I like mono loop for heavier tippet. I've had alot of flies cut right through smaller diameter tippet using the mono loop, so I quit using it for anything lighter than 3x.
 

Drifter

Active Member
#7
Well I'm going to use a loop knot alot more this year. I always stayed away from them because I just "HATE" the visibility of the knot when it is away from the eye of the hook. This is what has kept me away from using the loop knot!

In my head I can see how visible it is after tying it, when the fly is sinking I can see it. Yet I know it gives the fly more action I also think it can spook fish - well smart fish anyway! but so many people use it that I'm thinking I must be "OMG - WRONG" while fishing for trout I think they all have college degrees and flip me the fin if I do one thing wrong! When in all actuality they are like grade school kids when the lunch bell rings - running to get in line first at the lunch line and hopping apple pie is on the menu and eating everything in sight tell it's all gone!

I don't think it matters with a good chop or strong wind while fishing under indi's but, when it's calm and the water is flat it makes perfect sense to give the fly as much movement as you can with the loop knot!

Now I have to work on the way I think "ALL" trout are so smart - I mean sometimes I think they are actually smarter than I am. But it keeps me on my toes at all times!!! HMMMM
 

ryfly

Addicted to flyfishing
#9
Steve, it actually works really well for buggers and streamers as it allows that extra motion adding just a little bit more "life" to the action of the fly on the retrieve and on the fall. I also use it all nymphs in rivers as well.
 
#11
I usually try to do a non-slip loop with bigger flies but only because they are a little harder to pass through the loop of a double surgeon. The double surgeon is definitely easier with cold fingers though.
 

Richard E

Active Member
#12
Using a Perfection loop is a tradeoff. A nice, straight loop at the end of the line but less strength (using a Perfection Loop reduces tippet breaking strength by ~15%). I like it on the butt end of a leader for attaching loop-to-loop with a welded loop on the end of a fly line when losing a little breaking strength off a 15-20lb test leader won't likely make a difference. The non-slip mono loop is a 100% tippet strength knot . . .ideal for attaching the fly.
troutpocket speaks big medicine, and I agree wholeheartedly; for just about any reason, the non-slip mono loop woudl be preferred to the perfection loop in this instance. However, though the non-slip mono loop has a very high breaking strength, I don't believe it's quite 100%...
 
#14
I use the bowline loop knot for all flies. I've caught huge coho/kings in Alaska, Dorado in Cabo to rainbows everywhere. I even use it for dries as with small parachutes the loop won't trap any hackle fibers. I can tie this loop super small with a minimal of wasted tippet. Works for me!
 

ryfly

Addicted to flyfishing
#15
If I can tie the knot blindfolded and in the dark, its a plus. I just won't lay the pipe to the fish during fight.