Can you fly fish with hookless flies in closed waters?

CLO

Future WFF Mod
#1
I was just wondering if it's legal to fish with a hookless fly on closed rivers? I will most likely catch the same amount of fish as when using a hook but I just want to practice some casting.
 

Derek Young

Emerging Rivers Guide Services
#2
You're bound to draw attention to yourself, like the guy I called WDFW on today casting a bait rod on the Snoqualmie right above the FC bridge. If you have to have moving water, best to call ahead and let the WDFW know your intentions, so if a call does come in, they're aware of your presence and intentions. Take Aaron's Saturday morning casting lessons - they know he's there doing it.

So, avoid the hassle and plan ahead.
 

Dipnet

The wanted posters say Tim Hartman
#3
WDFW Sport Fishing Rules p. 10:

"Closed waters: A body of water where fishing is prohibited."

Note that it doesn't say "catching" so if you're tossing a hookless fly/lure you're probably still gonna be cited by a gamie.

Just my 2¢!

Disclaimer: I think I know everything but my wife often points out that I may be mistaken!! ;)
 

Krusty

Active Member
#4
Look...if you want to divert the very limited resources of Wildlife enforcement from dealing with serious poaching issues..........
 

Josh

dead in the water
#7
It's just one of those things where you are risking getting hassled. You can mitigate that somewhat by informing the WDFW that you are going to be out there casting or going somewhere that you are unlikely to run into anyone. But that still leaves you open to random law-enforcement interactions and/or nosy do-gooders. Will you get a ticket? Probably not if you really are casting with a clipped hook and don't have any real flies on your person. But to be honest, it probably depends on the mood of the officer you run into and your attitude when interacting with them.
 

Pat Lat

Mad Flyentist
#8
Isn't the whole occupy Skagit crew casting with hookless flies at the event. I'd think that tying a piece of yarn to show that you are obviously practice casting would work, but people would just think you were a dirty nympher from afar:) or maybe a yarnie purist
 

Irafly

Indi "Ira" Jones
#9
There is also the unfortunate side effect of others seeing you not knowing you are hookless and suddenly thinking the river is open for them as well. I know that's on them, but sometimes regardless of your intentions others copy inappropriately.
 

David Loy

Senior Moment
#13
IF you do it, you better not have ANY viable hooks with you.
You've probably heard the joke about the woman getting a ticket from WDFW officer. She wasn't actively fishing but there was a tacklebox in the boat so the officer reasoned she had all the necessary equipment. She counters with "OK then, I am suing you for attempted rape". He sez "but why". "Because you have all the necessary equipment with you". "Have a good day ma'am".
 

Ray

Active Member
#14
Just tie a bit of yarn to the end of your line and leave the hooks (clipped and unclipped) at home. No hooks=no fishing.
 

Salmo_g

Well-Known Member
#15
I was just wondering if it's legal to fish with a hookless fly on closed rivers? I will most likely catch the same amount of fish as when using a hook but I just want to practice some casting.
No, it's not legal to fish with hookless flies if the water is closed to fishing. However, you can practice your casting with hookless flies in closed waters, but it's advisable to notify WDFW LE ahead of time to avoid being hassled by them and cited for causing them to waste their time on you.

Sg
 

Latest posts