waddington shank verses tube flys

hydrological

beads are NOT flies and snagging is just ghetto
#3
less for a fish to leverage against w/ a tube fly. as long as youre using a short shank hook. w/ a wadd, shank is attatched to the hook, not sliding free.
 
#7
less for a fish to leverage against w/ a tube fly. as long as youre using a short shank hook. w/ a wadd, shank is attatched to the hook, not sliding free.
I think if the trailer hook on a shank is tied on with braid or something it's the same leverage since the pivot point is the hook eye.

Tubes are cheaper for sure. Easier to change hooks. You can tie them nice and light if you want. You don't have to plan out your fly, just chop off what's left at the end.

Shanks seem easier to tie on for me too. They seem better for heavy flies. Definitely more time consuming to tie in the trailer hook. Can't do beads or cones but hold lead eyes better.

I got through phases of tying on both. I seem to run winter flies on shanks and summer flies on traditional hooks or tubes.

In the end it's all car keys on the end of string...
 
#8
In my opinion, I think tubes are better then shanks in almost every way other then the fact the shanks are heavier than tubes. Tubes allow you to:
-Change hooks easier, no messing with wire,braid,mono,etc.
-Wire fatigue is not something you have to worry about, neither is wire twist
-Can tie larger and smaller flies then on shanks
-Can fish skaters with trailing hooks better
-stackable to change color/profile/size
-cheaper
-systems like protube allow infinite color/weight options

Again, just my opinion, but something to think about. Tubes, especially long rigid tubes fished in very cold air/water temps are prone to breaking if you strike rocks or snag up. tying a 45 minute tube intruder just to have it break in half kinda sucks. but thats why I like simple bunny/marabou tubes.
 
#9
In my opinion, I think tubes are better then shanks in almost every way other then the fact the shanks are heavier than tubes. Tubes allow you to:
-Change hooks easier, no messing with wire,braid,mono,etc.
-Wire fatigue is not something you have to worry about, neither is wire twist
-Can tie larger and smaller flies then on shanks
-Can fish skaters with trailing hooks better
-stackable to change color/profile/size
-cheaper
-systems like protube allow infinite color/weight options

Again, just my opinion, but something to think about. Tubes, especially long rigid tubes fished in very cold air/water temps are prone to breaking if you strike rocks or snag up. tying a 45 minute tube intruder just to have it break in half kinda sucks. but thats why I like simple bunny/marabou tubes.
if you use spinner bait shafts as a shank, you can tie flies up to about 7 inches long or as short as you want. and, they cost less than waddington shanks or tubes if you buy them in bulk.
 

flybill

Purveyor of fine hackle, wine & cigars!
#10
I love them both! Frodin tubes for me and Wadington shanks. Shanks are for flies you want more weight. Tubes for less weight. That's the main difference in my opinion. I have a couple of great Guideline tube needles that make is easy to tie tubes on my Regal vice! I have one of the old HMH tube fly attachments as well, but don't like it. Tubes are easy to tie on if you lay down a good thread base before you get going.

I've been meaning to try Enumer tubes and cones, but have a good amount of Frodin tubes, cones, etc.. What I really want is one of the new tube fly boxes from Off the Hook (http://www.offthehooktube.com/boxes.php). I'm tired of my plano boxes since the tube flies and articulated flies get all messed up. Gonna get the big one soon!
 
#11
Hook up percentage is a fickle beast because there are so many factors at play when a fish grabs your fly. But having the hook riding where it should be helps a ton.That said a tube fly with the hook eye pulled snug into the junction tubing is the best combo I've found especially for plucky summer runs and soft water winter runs. For a larger bodied or weighted winter bug I like waddington or similar shank with a wire stinger loop for durability and balance and improved hook posture while swimming. Bunny flies... I'm back where I started with spinner bait shanks and fireline loops threaded through the bunny. Just my $.02
 
#12
Waddingtons are also nice because if your stinger loop goes to shit you can thread your line through the fly and rig a hook tube fly style with junction tubing on the back loop for those rare times a fly lasts that long without being sacrificed to the river gods
 

g_smolt

Recreational User
#13
Tubes can be a pain to trim correctly, and if you tie dorso-ventral patterns (as opposed to in the round) on tubes, they have a tendency to ride on their sides - in faster water, they tend to spin.

For in-the-round patterns and skaters, they are great.

If you have the hook in the right place, I don't think you would see much difference in hookups and holds between the two.
 

James Mello

Inventor of the "closed eye conjecture"
#14
I'm interested in which style of fly ,waddington shank or tube fly results in more hook ups & why people think this is?

Shanks also have some built in mass. Adding a cone is different in terms of how the fly sinks versus having the mass more evenly distributed. Also, shanks are dirt cheap. Buying a 1000 spinner shanks costs me 11.50 and has set me up for a long time.

If you don't like the wire style set up for shanks, you can do the ol' skool rigging that Ed Ward and others did with junction tubiing and a mono 'eye hole' in the rear.
 

pbunbury

Tights Lines
#15
I love tubes, easy to tie, extremely versatile and customization is endless. I also don't miss many fish. I find that they are easy to weight if wanted with either the flexweights or dropweights, and all of mine swim true when fished regardless of water speed. They also offer way more versatility, customization, and sizing options than shanks. Just my .02

http://www.flyfishusa.com/fly-tying/pro-tube/pro-tube.htm - here's a pretty good run down