Washington Fly Fishing Forum banner
1 - 14 of 14 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
20 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
This is my first year fishing for cutthroat from the beaches and am wondering what do you do when the wave action stirs up the silt and clouds the water? Is it worth fishing this water? Are dark patterns the answer in this situation? Any tips or suggestions would be appreciated.

Cheers!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,520 Posts
Fish the current breaks where the water changes from darker to clearer. Not only are these rips always a good place to fish because they concentrate bait thus attracting fish but the faster current side of these rips will usually equal clearer water also increasing your fishing productivity. However this is a lot easier to accomplish from a boat than from shore. Plus if it is so windy to kick up sand in the shallows it is usually to windy for me to be motivated to fish. It can make for a rough day of casting.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,339 Posts
On a similar note how do you guys deal with the all the debris on the change of tides? If I can, I'll fish the edges of the debris path or look for pockets that mysteriously remain immune to debris. Otherwise I use this time to enjoy a cup of coffee and a cookie until the water clears. I've tried fishing full sinking lines with the idea that I can get under the debris with minimal amounts of salad collecting on my fly, but this usually doesn't pan out too well for me.
 

· Long Lost Member
Joined
·
20,410 Posts
One thing I've tried a time or two when there is a lot of debris...Cast into a gap or lane with an intermediate or "hover" line and an unweighted fly. Just let it drift. A euphasid pattern, fry or sand lance comes to mind a couple of times when I put the fly in a clear spot and just let it drift. BAM, fish on. I've been told a lot of these tide lines hold not only debris, but food stuck in the mess, following it along to feed themselves or for protection. Normally I'll have a few possible places with different beach angles of exposure to try. If I find one heavily dirtied up or full of debris then I'll move on to somewhere more sheltered. The Kitsap Peninsula has the drawback of no rivers to fish, but there is not much distance to travel to swap from a Puget Sound beach facing to the east to a Hood Canal beach facing to the west.

I know there are others out there, much more crafty anglers than I, that sometimes will cast and let the current carry their flies. They might not admit it up front, but they do it at times, and sometimes it actually works better than stripping fast, stripping slow or stripping erratic. Why not employ that in a clear spot in all that debris? If you are there and are not moving why not work on target casting the clear spots?
 

· Banned
Joined
·
5,346 Posts
I'd be careful about generalizing too much about never fishing turbid water. You can catch cutthroat and salmon in muddy or seaweed filled water under some circumstances. The #1 reason to fish turbid water is if there are baitfish in close to the beach using the low visibility water for cover. A few stories:

Once at a beach in the Nisqually Reach area I was staring out at the water while relaxing, and was disappointed to see the incoming tide was kicking up silt. I had my rod in my truck but I wasn't going to waste my time fishing that muddy flat with low visibility water. I quickly changed my mind about 20 minutes later when a small group of Bonaparte's gulls started taking baitfish out of the muddy shallow waters about 10 feet out from the beach. I grabbed my gear and waded out into the silty water and started blind casting a baitfish pattern. As I retrieved my first cast I saw a large pair of terrorized eyes swimming directly at me, just a few feet from my stripping basket. It was a herring with its swim bladder apparently damaged. A couple of seconds later a large cutthroat savagely struck it from below, missed, then hit it again. With my hands trembling I backed up toward shore and started fanning out casts into the murk. Within an hour I managed to land 2 very well fed cutthroat and missed some others.

That same year I visited a north sound beach that fished well on an outgoing tide. I arrived at the peak of the high tide and made some phone calls, waiting for the tide to ebb and take away the copious amounts of floating seaweed and eelgrass. While talking on the phone my jaw dropped as the large area of floating debris started to erupt in violent slashes and jumps of feeding cutthroat and salmon. Apparently a large group of juvenile sandlance had started to shelter amongst the seaweed and the predators were starting to gorge themselves. I hung up the phone and started tossing out a baitfish pattern and managed to land one nice cutthroat and a lot of salad. The outgoing tide rapidly took away the seaweed, baitfish, and all those feeding cutthroat and salmon. It was one of the most amazing feeding frenzies I've ever seen, but it wouldn't have happened without the seaweed.

Last story. I was fishing a Case Inlet beach in March '07 looking for cutthroat feeding on chum fry. I found the chum fry in very close to shore sheltering in shallow water. They were still tiny and weak swimmers, but there were large schools of them. The tide was going out fast and the wind started to blow into shore, kicking up silt from the muddy bottom. The visibility of the water 6 feet out from the beach was poor at best and the chum fry were hanging out in the turbid water. A few cutthroat and small resident silvers were in the area, but the fishing was sporadic and I had to cover a lot of beach. The most effective approach was to walk the beach and start casting parallel to the shore and strip my fly slowly. Over the course of the day I landed about 10 cutthroat and silvers, the majority of them in close to shore in the silty water using a variety of small baitfish patterns. The cutthroat were using the muddy water and wind blown waves to cover their shallow water feeding attacks, and the chum fry were just trying not to be seen. One of these muddy water cutties was very large:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,339 Posts
I never tried dead drifting along the debris. I like the concept of food floating along with the debris and fish cruising the edges and sampling the buffet. I've cast flies to kekp beds searching for feeding coho. This has been really succesful at times. Dead drifting along the debris seems like a similar tactic.

I have used the current to swing flies as I would in the river or to drift them like a nymph. At the end of the swing/drift I use an eratic stip to bring the fly back up against the current. This works often enough that I try it when the current is really moving. I find it a relaxing way to fish too.

Thanks for the input everyone.
 
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top