Josh, Great post! i agree with your assessment completely. These financial institutions should be allowed to fail. This bailout proposal is socialism by any other name, and verging on fascism.
Any executives that made lousy, risky decisions for any of these financial institutions should be required to give all of their bonus back. No golden parachutes. Why should they skate with our dough? Where do think those extra "points" on your loans went to? Some of it paid for commissions and bonuses for these robbers.
I just viewed a vid on Yahoo Finance with some talking heads suggesting we take the route Sweden did when they were faced with a similar crisis. No bailout. Make the lending institutions bite the bullet and write down their bad loans and go from there.
This isn't Sweden, and it might not work the same here.
I just had a thought: Any corporations that might need to raise capital might have to issue more shares of stock if they can't get a loan. This will be dilutive to the company's stock price. If you own shares of any company that is carrying a lot of debt already, and has no free cash flow, lookout! They won't be able to borrow any money for their needs.
My market observations lately lead me to conclude that the big money is still using every ralley attempt to sell their positions. They can't just liquidate all at once without crashing the price of the stock being liquidated. It takes a while for these funds to unwind a large position. Whenever "joe public" investors bail out of mutual funds, the fund managers must return them their money. Sometimes, the funds must sell even good, fairly valued stocks to raise the capital, if the fund is being vacated by enough fleeing investors. They have to raise the cash somehow. This "redemption selling" on a massive scale will (and has been doing so) drag down the entire market.
Individual investors with relatively small positions, can just hit the sell button and go to 100% cash until there is some clarity about what's going to happen with all of this, and thus protect their capital. I missed a good opportunity to do just that several times this year, the last one being on Friday. :beathead: Late April would have been skookum! But I like to trade...and still have some skin in the game. I see road rash in my future.
Perhaps this suddenly announced bailout plan was issued to head off the panic that was affecting the markets last week, to allow the big money a chance to liquidate some more before the value of their total assets declines any further. The market sure did pop on the announcement, but now it is selling off again.
I'm sort of a CFA, but that stands for Certifiable Fish Aholic