Generic quote - "shut down the river until its wild fish rebound"
I myself have made this comment many times over the years about some fishery or another. Trouble is this approach hasn't seen much success. You're still only dealing with two facets of the problem, harvest (edit: part of the harvest) and hatcheries.
Another aspect of closures I see given little consideration is what about all the displaced anglers? Say we close the Washougal, now those guys are going somewhere else, say the E. Fork Lewis, or the N. Fork Lewis, maybe the Kalama, or perhaps they'll head on up and hit the Klick (in season) (yeah I skipped a few rivers). Each of these other watersheds have their own troubles with their wild steelhead. What happens when we push the angling pressure to them?
Don't they warrant the same concern for their wild fish populations? Oh I have an idea lets just close them all down. Can we really afford to shut down an entire industry in one fell swoop of the pen? No I'm not saying the almighty buck should always trump the wild fish but there are ramifications beyond just closing down a particular watershed.
Lets see wasn't it just a season or two ago that a bunch of the S rivers were shut down. I seem to recall a hue and cry across several 'virtual communities' about all the displaced anglers ending up over on the OP and the extra pressure those local rivers faced.
Shut down all of SWWA and coming soon to a river near you, yep you guessed it, a bunch of us. Don't those rivers warrant the same concern, wait, I'm starting to see a pattern here, BIG rock in a small pool kind of thing, the waves radiating out, hitting the banks, bouncing back, all kinds of cross ripples and conflicting wavelets smashing into each other.
Not saying you're wrong to feel that closure is an answer, just saying we might need to step back and take a look at a little larger canvas.
Out of concern for wild fish,how many put down their rods? I can tell you that I and any of the anglers I'm fishing with have only hit the Washougal once in the past two years due to concerns about its depressed runs.
Don't have all or even any of the answers, just more questions.
~w